Indexing Gets Personal

Indexing is starting to look like a service, not a single product. Direct indexing and custom benchmarks let investors keep “market beta” while changing the rules around taxes, screens, and constraints. Direct indexing ended 2024 at $864.3 billion, a meaningful base but still far below $9.4 trillion in index ETFs and $6.6 trillion in index mutual funds.

In this article, we explore how advances in portfolio construction and tax management are driving demand for customized index exposures. Our analysis treats personalization as an extension of indexing, and looks at how it shifts distribution, scalability, and competition.

Tax Management Turns Customization Into A Feature, Not A Philosophy

Assets in tax-managed SMAs rose to more than $500 billion in 2024, up 67% from the end of 2022. That growth frames personalization in plain terms: it is often sold as a tax tool first, and an index tool second. The pitch is not that markets changed, but that wrappers did.

Direct indexing’s appeal is strongest when investors can harvest losses while keeping index-like exposure. That creates a new kind of “tracking error,” where the portfolio may look different, yet still behave like the market. In practice, the difference is not the benchmark return, but the after-tax path to it.

Schwab markets Personalized Indexing with fees starting at 0.40% and a $100,000 minimum. That price point signals where personalization is trying to go next: down-market, but not all the way to retail micro-accounts. It also makes the business model clear, since customization needs a platform, not just a cheap fund.

What If Washington Declared That:
YOUR Money ISN'T Actually Yours?

❝

Sounds insane, but that's exactly what the Department of Justice just admitted in court — claiming cash isn't legally your property.

What does that mean? It means Washington thinks they can seize, freeze, or drain your accounts — whenever they want.

• Your savings? At risk.

• Your retirement? Up for grabs.

• Your financial future? Under their control.

This isn't just some legal theory. It's happening right now.

But you don't have to be their next target.

Smart Americans are already making moves to keep their wealth out of Washington's reach — before the next financial lockdown.

We put together a Brand New Wealth Defense Guide that reveals 3 powerful strategies to shield your savings before it's too late.

Because once the trap snaps shut, it'll be too late to escape.

Custom Benchmarks Turn Indexing Into Software

In 2024, global index industry revenue hit a record $6.4 billion, up 12.8% year over year. That number matters because customization increases demand for index design, licensing, and data governance. A personalized portfolio still needs a ruleset, and someone needs to define and maintain it.

Index-based products across ETFs, mutual funds, and direct indexing SMAs crossed $16 trillion in assets by year-end 2024. That scale keeps the center of gravity in traditional index vehicles, even as customization grows around the edges. It also explains why “custom benchmarks” are becoming a competitive lever, not a niche add-on.

A key shift is that the benchmark no longer has to match a ticker. That breaks the old link between index exposure and a single fund wrapper. It creates room for “beta menus,” where two investors can both own U.S. large caps, but with different exclusions and tax settings.

Direct Indexing Is Growing, But Distribution Decides How Big It Gets

Only 18% of advisors reported using direct indexing in 2024, up from 16% in 2023. That adoption rate shows the limiting factor is not product availability. It is workflow, client fit, and the ability to explain outcomes that may differ from a headline index.

Cerulli also found 26% of advisors opted out despite having access, and 12% said they did not know what direct indexing was. Those figures read like a distribution problem more than a performance problem. If the story were obvious, awareness would not be a barrier.

The market is also concentrated, with reports noting the top providers control a large share of direct indexing assets. Concentration helps with scale because big platforms can automate rebalancing, tax lots, and reporting. It can also harden the moat, since personalization improves when the tech and the data are tightly integrated.

Personalization Competes With ETFs By Sitting Next To Them

Global ETF assets reached about $15 trillion in 2024, reflecting how strong the plain-vanilla vehicle remains. That matters because personalization is not replacing ETFs at the system level. It is competing for a slice of the same “beta budget,” usually in wealth channels where taxes and constraints are more visible.

Direct indexing’s share can grow even if ETF share keeps growing too. The category does not need to “win” to matter; it only needs to shift how firms bundle indexing with advice, planning, and reporting. That is why the fight feels like platform versus platform, not fund versus fund.

Fees also shape the map. When personalization costs multiples of an ETF, the value has to show up in clear tax outcomes, clearer constraint handling, or both. In calm markets with fewer losses, that value can look less dramatic.

Risks And Limitations

Personalization adds moving parts, and moving parts raise the odds of client confusion. A portfolio can track the market closely and still look unfamiliar because the holdings are different. That gap can strain trust if reporting is weak.

Tax outcomes vary by market path and investor profile. Loss harvesting is easier after drawdowns, and harder in steady up markets. The feature is real, but it does not produce uniform benefits every year.

Costs and minimums still gate access. Even at lower minimums, direct indexing sits above mass-market pricing. That keeps the core of indexing anchored in ETFs and mutual funds.

Conclusion

Customized beta is turning indexing into a configurable stack, with taxes and constraints as the main drivers. The data shows direct indexing is still smaller than ETFs, but large enough to shape platform design and index economics.

The next index frontier looks less like a new benchmark and more like a new operating model, where measurement, implementation, and tax rules are packaged together.

Recommended publications

View more
caret-right